Sunday Worship at 10 AM 95 Eastchester Road, New Rochelle, NY
Watch Services on YouTube

About St. Luke's

A welcoming Lutheran congregation in New Rochelle, gathering in faith since 1855.

Our Mission

The Mission of St. Luke's Lutheran Church is to share the good news of Jesus through word and sacrament, serving, teaching, and welcoming our community.

“Go therefore and make disciples of all nations.”
Matthew 28:19 — the Great Commission that shapes our mission

By God's acceptance of us in Holy Baptism, we have been marked as a people called to reach out and welcome all. Rooted in the catholic faith, renewed by the rediscovered freedom of the Gospel in the Protestant Reformation; energized by the message of God's love through faith alone in the crucified and resurrected Christ, our mission is to spread the Word of God through the gifts we have been given. Foremost is the gift of God's living Word, Jesus Christ, coming to us through Holy Scripture and sacraments. We are a people who enjoy diverse backgrounds, yet, in common we share our struggles while affirming the gifts of faith, hope, love, and forgiveness. Come visit, worship, and grow with us.

St. Luke's is a member congregation of the Metropolitan New York Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA).

Our History

What began with a handful of German immigrant families praying in their living rooms has grown into a diverse congregation that has called New Rochelle home for more than 170 years and three church buildings.

Painting of the first St. Luke's, a white wooden church with a pointed bell tower
1870

Our first church

Washington Avenue and Charles Street

Painting of the second St. Luke's, a stone church with a tall steeple and rose window
1900

A larger stone church

Built for a fast-growing congregation

Painting of today's St. Luke's on Eastchester Road
1957

Our home today

95 Eastchester Road

Through the years

  1. 1855

    German Lutheran immigrants begin worshiping in their native language in the homes of two families, the Mahlstedts and the Popps.

  2. 1869 – 1871

    The congregation buys property, organizes with a five-member council and dedicates its first church on May 22, 1870. Rev. Alexander Von Schlichten becomes the first resident pastor in 1871.

  3. 1900

    Growth under Rev. Martin W. Gaudian (1890–1898) leads to a larger church, dedicated March 25, 1900. Its marble baptismal font, a gift of the Sunday School, is still used for baptisms today. A pipe organ, stained glass, electric lighting and mosaics follow.

  4. 1945

    As German-language worship fades, the German Evangelical Lutheran St. Lukas Church becomes St. Luke's Evangelical Lutheran Church of the City of New Rochelle.

  5. 1946 – 1957

    The planned New England Thruway claims the church's property. St. Luke's buys land on Eastchester Road in 1954, breaks ground on October 2, 1955, and dedicates its new church on March 24, 1957, bringing its windows and mosaics along.

  6. 1952 – 1969

    Under Pastor George Heck, membership grows from 285 to 405, and the congregation celebrates burning its mortgage on November 13, 1966.

  7. 1989 – 2022

    Pastor William Damrow, our longest-serving pastor, leads St. Luke's for 33 years and widens the role of lay members in worship.

  8. 2002

    When their church closes, members of a Norwegian congregation join St. Luke's, and their representatives now serve on our congregation council.

  9. Today

    Our members trace their roots to Germany, Scandinavia and many other places. Fellowship is still at the heart of who we are — the old church Bazaar lives on as our Holiday Boutique and Holiday Café.

Heritage We Carried With Us

The German heritage of St. Luke’s is evident, as the church contains two 5-ft mosaic murals, that are dedicated to Catherine and Albert Mahstedt the Christian witnesses who started the church and shepherded its early development. These mosaics, depicting Moses with the 10 commandments and Jesus, were cut out of a wall in the former church building. Builders refused to move them in case they got damaged, so the men of the church community moved them by flatbed truck. Also moved were stained-glass windows of scenes from Jesus’ life that grace the walls and were designed in Germany with German language dedications. These are reminders of the determination, faith and generosity of these past members.

Gold mosaic of Moses holding the tablets of the Ten Commandments
Gold mosaic of Jesus in a white robe and red mantle

Be part of the next chapter.

Join us Sunday at 10 AM, then stay for coffee and conversation.